HSA Fees Compared: Percentage, Flat and Annual Models

Two friends in toques laugh as they split the bill at the counter of a busy Edmonton ramen bar on a snowy night, with steaming bowls in front of them and a lit streetcar crossing a bridge outside, painted in a 1970s pulp halftone style

Quick answer

Pick the fee model by your expected claims. If claims are low or uncertain, a percentage with no fixed fee costs nothing in a quiet year: Frontier charges 8% of approved claims plus applicable taxes, for incorporated businesses outside Quebec. Coastal's 7% costs less once first-year claims pass $5,000, and at any claim amount above $0 after year one.

This guide is published by Frontier HSA and was last reviewed on November 18, 2026. Amounts are Canadian dollars before applicable taxes unless stated otherwise.

The three ways HSA administrators charge

A Health Spending Account (a Canadian employer plan, not the American savings account) has two costs. The corporation pays the approved claims. It also pays the administrator. That second cost comes in three basic models, and some providers mix them.

  1. Percentage of approved claims. You pay a share of every dollar approved. No claims means no fee.
  2. Flat amounts per claim or per member. You pay a dollar amount for each claim, or for each person added to the plan. Claim count and headcount drive the bill, not just claim dollars.
  3. Annual or setup fees. You pay a fixed amount once at the start, every year, or both. These are owed whether anyone claims or not.

A low percentage can sit next to a setup fee. The only fair test is a whole year's total at your expected claims.

Which model each provider uses

These are the published terms we checked on November 9, 2026, for our comparison of Canadian HSA providers.

  • Frontier HSA: percentage only. Our pricing is 8% of approved claims plus applicable taxes, with no setup, monthly, annual or per-employee fees.
  • Coastal HSA: percentage plus setup. A 7% claim fee and a one-time $50 setup fee, with no annual fee. Member-addition fees: confirm with Coastal.
  • Olympia Group HSA: all three models combined. 8% of claims, $99 a year, $335 once for setup, and $40 for each member added.
  • Olympia Basic: flat annual. $249 a year with no claim fee. It is an owner plan with a published $15,000 annual claim limit, so it is not priced for a 10-person team.
  • Kibono: per-claim flat amount plus percentage. $2.25 plus 5.25% per claim, with no setup or annual fee. Payment processing is extra: $1.50 plus 1.50% for direct debit, or $0.30 plus 3.50% by card.
  • EasyHSA: percentage only. 10% of approved claims, with no signup, annual or employee-addition fee.
  • Wellbytes: percentage, or an annual plan. Pay-As-You-Use is 10% with no setup or subscription fee. The annual plan needs a quote.
  • Quikcard: percentage. No signup fee, and a claim charge it says is typically 12%. Confirm the full schedule.
  • myHSA and Canada Life's HCSA: quote required. myHSA uses a percentage model without a published universal rate. Canada Life's page has no standalone fee schedule.

What a 10-person team pays in three kinds of year

An incorporated engineering firm in Edmonton, Alberta, puts its 10 people (including the owner, who works in the business on salary) in one class with a $3,000 limit each. We price three years of approved claims: a quiet year with $0, a normal year with $10,000 and a heavy year with $30,000.

Year two assumes the same 10 members and no new hires. Fees are before GST. In Alberta, GST at 5% applies to the administration fee only, not to the claims. Add the approved claims to any fee to get what the corporation pays before tax.

Provider (model) $0, year 1 $0, year 2 $10,000, year 1 $10,000, year 2 $30,000, year 1 $30,000, year 2
Frontier HSA (8%) $0 $0 $800 $800 $2,400 $2,400
Coastal HSA (7% + $50 setup) $50 $0 $750 $700 $2,150 $2,100
Olympia Group (8% + fixed fees) $834 $99 $1,634 $899 $3,234 $2,499
EasyHSA (10%) $0 $0 $1,000 $1,000 $3,000 $3,000
Wellbytes Pay-As-You-Use (10%) $0 $0 $1,000 $1,000 $3,000 $3,000
Kibono ($2.25 + 5.25% per claim) $0 $0 $525 + $2.25 per claim + processing Same as year 1 $1,575 + $2.25 per claim + processing Same as year 1
Quikcard (typically 12%) Quote Quote Quote Quote Quote Quote
myHSA, Canada Life HCSA Quote Quote Quote Quote Quote Quote

Olympia Group's year one is $335 setup, $99 annual and $400 for 10 members added, plus 8% of claims. Its year two drops the setup and member charges. Coastal's year two drops the $50 setup fee. Their published pages don't list a member charge for Coastal, Kibono or Wellbytes, so their rows assume none; confirm with each provider. "Quote" means no published total, not $0.

With GST, Frontier's normal year is $800 plus $40, so the corporation pays $10,840 including the claims. Its heavy year is $2,400 plus $120, for $32,520. Its quiet year is $0.

Where each model wins

No fixed fee protects a quiet year. Frontier, EasyHSA, Wellbytes Pay-As-You-Use and Kibono all cost $0 when nobody claims. Frontier's 8% is lower than the 10% rates at every claim amount above $0.

A lower percentage with a small setup fee wins as claims grow. Coastal costs less than Frontier once first-year claims pass $5,000, where both charge $400. At $10,000, Coastal is $50 cheaper in year one and $100 cheaper in year two. At $30,000, it is $250 cheaper in year one and $300 cheaper in year two. After the setup year, Coastal's 7% is lower than our 8% at any claim amount above $0.

Per-claim pricing wins when each claim is large. Before processing charges, Kibono's $2.25 plus 5.25% is lower than 8% when the average claim is above about $82. Many small receipts push it the other way. Processing charges and Kibono's eligibility checklist (salaried T4 employees and at least 50% non-related employees) both need checking first.

Flat annual fees win for one owner with high claims. Olympia Basic's $249 is lower than Frontier's 8% once claims pass $3,112.50, within its plan limit. It is an owner plan, though, not the plan for a team.

Combined models cost the most in a quiet year. Olympia Group charges 8% like Frontier, so its fixed charges are on top at every claim amount. That's $834 in year one even with no claims. The provider fee benchmark runs more scenarios with the same published terms.

Per-member charges as your team changes

A per-member charge follows every hire. At Olympia Group, every person added costs $40, so replacing two people in a year adds $80. Ask whether the charge applies again at renewal.

With Frontier, adding or removing staff changes nothing on the fee. You pay 8% of what is approved plus applicable taxes, whoever claims it.

What the fee sheet doesn't show

Funding. Some plans collect money before claims arrive. myHSA offers pay-as-you-go or prefunded arrangements. Kibono offers monthly or prepaid funding. Coastal collects claims and fees by pre-authorized debit with no upfront deposit. Frontier has no deposit: a limit is a ceiling, not a bill. Our guide to HSAs without upfront funding compares the options.

Claim speed. Coastal advertises two to four business days for reimbursement; confirm the timing for your plan. Quikcard runs payments twice a week. At Frontier, after approval we invoice the corporation for the claim, the 8% fee and applicable taxes. With automatic bank payments, the employee is paid when the debit starts. With manual invoices, it's once the invoice is paid.

Cancellation terms. Ask about contract length, notice periods and cancellation fees before you sign. Frontier has no contract and no cancellation fee. For other providers, get the terms in writing; we did not compare them.

What we recommend

Choose the model by how much your team will claim and how steady those claims are. If claims are low, new or hard to predict, avoid annual and per-member fees so a quiet year costs $0. Frontier charges 8% of approved claims plus applicable taxes, for incorporated businesses outside Quebec: $800 plus $40 GST on the Edmonton firm's $10,000 year, and nothing per member as staff change. If your claims are steady, Coastal's 7% costs less once first-year claims pass $5,000, and at any claim amount in later years, by $100 a year at $10,000. Whatever you pick, total a whole year, including setup, annual and per-member fees, before you sign. If Frontier fits, check your eligibility first.

FAQ

Which HSA fee model is cheapest?

It depends on your claims. With low or uncertain claims, a percentage with no fixed fee costs nothing in a quiet year. With steady, higher claims, a lower percentage can win even with a setup fee: Coastal's 7% plus $50 costs less than Frontier's 8% once first-year claims pass $5,000. Fixed fees cost the same whether anyone claims.

Does a setup fee count in year two?

No. A one-time setup fee belongs only in year one. Coastal publishes $50 once and Olympia Group publishes $335 once. Recurring charges, such as Olympia Group's $99 annual fee, belong in every year. Model year two with only the recurring charges, plus any fee for members you add that year.

Is a per-member fee charged every year?

Read the wording. Olympia Group publishes $40 for each member added, which we treat as a charge when someone joins, so 10 members cost $400 at setup and each new hire adds $40. Ask the provider whether the charge also applies again at renewal. Frontier has no per-member fee.

Is GST charged on HSA administration fees?

In Alberta, GST at 5% applies to the administration fee, not to the approved claim. On $10,000 of claims, Frontier's $800 fee adds $40 GST, so the corporation pays $10,840. Other provinces charge HST or other provincial taxes, so ask each provider for a sample invoice in your province.

Why does the number of claims matter?

Some providers charge a dollar amount on every claim. Kibono charges $2.25 plus 5.25% per claim, plus payment processing. Ten $100 claims and one $1,000 claim are the same claim dollars but different Kibono fees. For a percentage-only provider, only the total approved dollars matter, not how many receipts there are.

Does the fee come out of the employee's reimbursement?

Not with Frontier. The employee receives the full approved claim. After approval, Frontier invoices the corporation for the claim, the 8% fee and applicable taxes. The corporation pays all three. Ask any other provider the same question, and get a sample invoice that shows the claim and each fee on separate lines.

Simplify Your Business Health Benefits

Get Started